Modern times call for modern solutions. Turning back the clock to a simpler time is idealistic hogwash. I think we need to be very hard-nosed in separating fact from fiction or we risk being led astray by empty promises and the allure of conformity.
This is especially true of those who are hurting or have aspirations that exceed their grasp. Actually, I don't know that “faith” was ever much use in turning people’s lives around. It is hard reality. That loud “smack” when you hit a brick wall that wakes you up.
As it turns out this may be less of a modern concept than it appears on the surface. The list of doubting Thomases is a long and august one. Shall we start with Abraham who did not trust God to give him a son by Sarah? He is most famous for his willingness to sacrifice Isaac. But the lesser known stories of his lack of faith, leaving for Egypt; asking Sarah to claim to be his sister; taking his father along to Haran are overlooked. Abraham was a man of faith but weak faith through the first 70 years of his life. And what was the turning point? It was not God's test of Abraham but Abraham's test of God. “How am I to know this is true?” he asked. He was asking God for proof. He was not ready to have full faith without proof. The proof God gave was the long awaited son born to him and Sarah after both were beyond child bearing years. Abraham’s renowned faith was the result of concrete proof.
Gideon, a remarkable example, was a coward. A “God takes care of those who care for themselves” kind of guy. He was winnowing grain in a winepress. That was so that he could hide from the Philistines. He did not have faith in God to protect him; he was going to keep out of sight. But God called and Gideon's response was “prove it”. He told God he would obey only if he had proof. God was to make a bundle of wool dry when all around it was wet. God did it. Gideon was not going to have faith based on one observation. He said, essentially, “Now do the reverse - let the wool be wet and everything else be dry.” Remember the “vengeful God” of the Old Testament. This is the point where he answers with a well placed lightening bolt. Well, that wasn't God's view. Maybe God doesn't trust people that are too easily convinced. After the second test Gideon was convinced. Gideon’s faith to win a great victory at impossible odds was the result of concrete proof. (Judges 6-7)
A final example is the most direct. Isaiah comes to king Ahaz. Ahaz and the people are very scared of the approaching armies so they need their faith bolstered. Isaiah says “Ask God for a sign.” Ahaz sounded like he didn't know the stories of Abraham and Gideon. He said, “Far be it from me to ask God for a sign.” With clear anger God responds essentially, “Oh, you are too good for a sign! Well, I'll give you one anyway. The mother of all signs.” (Isaiah 7:10-16)
The Bible says “Taste and see the goodness of The Lord.” (Ps 34:8) It is like someone offering you a new entree. No matter how much faith you have in his/er cooking you just don't know about that salmon upside-down cake until you taste it. God doesn't just suggest you to test him, he demands it.
But tasting is a bit different from testing. When you test you stand outside and look at results. When you taste you get personally involved. It's “com'on in, the water's fine”. Alas, there is water and there is water. Do you mean the Jewish Water (which was the context of the original quote), the Catholic Water, one of any number of Protestant waters? Baskin Robbins had nothing on human religion for variety.
The first thing to recognize is that “practice”, traditions and ceremonies, have little to do with faith. Some modern Jewish traditions are in the Bible and very few of the Christian traditions are in the Bible. So there are no promises related to those traditions. Certain behavior, however, is taught by the Bible and has specific promises associated with them.
Come on to me all those that travail and are heavy ladened and I will refresh you. Taste 1: Bring your worries and troubles to Jesus and he will refresh you. He actually may not remove those troubles, but he will assuredly give you strength. Well, feeling good is OK, but that could just be the “placebo effect.”
With the measure with which you measure out, it will be measured onto you. Taste 2: Try being giving to others and you will be given to. Try opening your hands and offering to others without restraint. You will begin to receive without bounds.
There are many other promises in the Bible but all are based on one fundamental principle. Don’t be afraid to put God to the test. He knows we need concrete results on which to base our faith and will not let you down.